From time to time I will contributing to CBS News and the Early Show’s parenting section and their Eye on Parenting blog. I’ll also post the content here and encourage everyone to visit Eye on Parenting and engage in the conversation there. Today’s discussion centers around the increased amount of public schools adopting uniform dress code policies.
Ryan's wardrobe choices fuel her independence and self identity.
It was recently announced that children at Rosemont Elementary School in Orlando and at least 10 other central Florida schools have changed or put new emphasis on their uniform dress code policy for the new school year.
When I first read about the movement many public schools are making towards uniform dress code policies — according to the U.S. Department of Education, the percentage of public schools requiring uniforms has risen from 3 to 18 percent since 1996 — I was torn. Having gone to a small private school where there was a fairly strict dress code with a formal uniform on Wednesdays, I think back on that experience with both positive and negative reactions that certainly impact my view on the topic with respect to my two daughters.
I can vividly recall being frustrated with having to wear specific styles and colors of clothes to conform to dress code and can remember going so far as to resort to non-standard socks, shoelaces or belts to weave some element of personality into my outfits. At the same time — let’s be realistic — I was a school age boy more concerned with who was pitching for the Red Sox that evening than what I was going to be wearing to school that day. Not having to concern myself with clothing choices in the morning or the tortures of school shopping with Mom had it’s own distinct benefits.
With a young girl in the house, I’ve learned however, that my experience as they relate to clothing aren’t representative of the reality in which I now find myself. For my daughter, choosing her own outfits each morning — and having some representation in what clothing gets purchased to fill the closet she picks from — is one of both the highlights and most dramatic moments of the day. Eventually, she’ll come in with some form of a long, flowing, brightly colored bohemian dress and I’ve come to respect her personal sense of style. It has been especially interesting for me to watch how independent choice of her own outfits have been followed with a more confident and independent sense of self with friends and peers. I find this personal development and correlation between independent choice and self worth to be the most troubling aspect of the possibility of her being corralled into a uniform dress code.
On one hand, I can respect parents who say the uniforms help them save money, and teachers that believe they help promote unity, order and academic seriousness. I think both are extremely valid points and worth consideration by public school boards. Looking back on my own experience, I do think that there is a sense of unity and structure that results from dress codes that is positive for the learning environment.
I can also appreciate the thought — and the potential recouping of fifteen lost minutes each morning pining over my daughter’s closet — that uniforms make mornings less stressful when a child is thinking about what outfit to represent their own personal brand or identity that day.
But for me, the benefits of freedom of thought and expression and the tie to a creation and ownership of personal identity is too valuable to lose. While I fully support measures to take actions to “clean up” the clothing that many children wear to school these days — whether too promiscuous or too profane — I don’t think a strict white polo and khaki skirt or pants uniform is right for my children’s personal development.
Share this post
